Human Rights
Posted on DELI

When Domestic Courts Defy Strasbourg: Safeguarding the Integrity of the European Convention on Human Rights

On 30 November 2026, the Dublin European Law Institute at Dublin City University, in partnership with the AGORA Group, will host a webinar on When Domestic Courts Defy Strasbourg: Safeguarding the Integrity of the European Convention on Human Rights. The webinar will take place online via Zoom from 17:00 to 18:30 (Dublin/London) | 18:00 to 19:30 (Brussels).

Register for the webinar

The protection of human rights in the Council of Europe rests on the binding nature of judgments of the European Court of Human Rights, as Article 46 of the Convention requires. Despite this, domestic courts have at times refused to comply with those judgments. Examples include the Russian Constitutional Court from 2016, Azerbaijan’s failure to execute the Mammadov judgment, which led the Committee of Ministers to use the Article 46 § 4 infringement procedure for the first time, and the Polish Constitutional Court in 2021. Most recently, on 13 October 2026, a lower criminal court in Türkiye declared the Court’s Kavala (No. 2) judgment unlawful. That ruling keeps Mr Kavala in prison, where he has been unlawfully held for nine years.

Speakers will examine how the Council of Europe system and national legal systems respond when domestic courts defy Strasbourg. They will discuss what mechanisms exist to protect the binding nature of the Court’s judgments, and what roles fall to the Court itself, to apex courts, to government agents and to national parliaments.

Programme:

17:00 Welcome and Introduction
Chair: Dr Andrew Forde, Deputy Director of the Dublin European Law Institute, Dublin City University

17:05 Panel Discussion

  • Prof Helen Keller, Professor of Law, University of Zurich, and former Judge of the European Court of Human Rights
  • Prof Michele Nicoletti, Professor of Political Philosophy, University of Trento, and former President of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)
  • Prof Renata Uitz, Professor of Comparative Constitutional Law and Co-Director of the CEU Democracy Institute, Central European University
  • Prof Adam Bodnar, Professor of Law, SWPS University, Warsaw, Senator of the Republic of Poland, and former Polish Minister of Justice and Ombudsman
  • Prof Başak Çalı, Professor of International Law and Head of Research, Bonavero Institute for Human Rights, University of Oxford
  • Prof Philip Leach, Professor of Human Rights Law, Middlesex University, and former Director of the European Human Rights Advocacy Centre (EHRAC)

18:30 Close

Related Content